Appeals Court Says States Can Regulate Sports Event Contracts

TL;DR On September 25, 2026, a unanimous three-judge panel of the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals sided with Ohio and Tennessee against Kalshi. The court said Kalshi had not shown that its sports event contracts are “swaps,” a category that would put them under the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). It added that even if they were swaps, federal law would not stop those states from enforcing their gambling laws. This was a ruling on preliminary injunctions, not a final verdict, and other appeals courts disagree. As of November 8, 2026, the fight is heading toward the Supreme Court.
Key takeaways
- The 6th Circuit upheld the denial of Kalshi’s injunction in Ohio and wiped out its injunction in Tennessee, sending that case back to the lower court.
- It decided whether Kalshi could block the states for now. The underlying lawsuits are still going.
- Appeals courts are split: the 3rd Circuit sided with Kalshi in April, the 9th Circuit against it in August.
- As of early November, Kalshi has asked the full 6th Circuit to rehear the case, and New Jersey’s Supreme Court petition is pending.
- What applies to you depends on your state. Help is free at 1-800-MY-RESET or 1-800-522-4700.
What the court decided
The cases are KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler (Ohio, No. 26-3196) and KalshiEX LLC v. Orgel (Tennessee, No. 26-5235), argued on July 30, 2026. Judges Clay, Gibbons and Bloomekatz heard them, and Judge Julia Smith Gibbons wrote the opinion.
The other side was state officials. In Ohio, that meant the Ohio Casino Control Commission, its members and the attorney general. In Tennessee, it meant the chair and executive director of the Tennessee Sports Wagering Council and the attorney general.
The outcome in each state
In Ohio, a federal district court had refused Kalshi a preliminary injunction, and the 6th Circuit affirmed. In Tennessee, a district court had granted one in February 2026. The appeals court vacated it and sent the case back.
The two holdings
First, Kalshi had not shown that its sports contracts are swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act. Second, and independently, the court said that even if they were swaps, the Act does not preempt Ohio’s or Tennessee’s gambling laws.
We could not open the full opinion, so the reasoning below comes from news summaries. According to The Block, the court read the statute’s phrase about “financial, economic, or commercial consequences” narrowly, to cover events inherently tied to a financial outcome, like interest rates or debt defaults. A game’s ripple effects on sponsors or local businesses were too remote. The court also found that the states’ laws regulate sports betting and touch exchanges like Kalshi only incidentally.
What the ruling does not decide
Kalshi sought preliminary injunctions, which are temporary court orders. The court held that Kalshi had not shown its contracts are swaps. That is different from a final judgment that they are illegal gambling.
- Not a final ruling. The Tennessee case went back to the district court, and the main lawsuits continue.
- Not a national rule. A circuit court’s decision binds federal courts in its own region. Other regions have ruled differently.
- Not a Supreme Court answer. The justices have not yet said whether they will take up the question.
- Not about users. The case is between a company and state officials, so it does not tell you what any state would do about customers.
How the appeals courts line up
The fight over whether sports event contracts are federally regulated “swaps” or state-regulated bets is playing out in several circuits. Scoreboard as of November 7, 2026:
| Court | When | Case | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3rd Circuit | April 2026 | New Jersey | 2 to 1 for Kalshi. The court held that the CFTC has exclusive authority over swaps. |
| 9th Circuit | August 28, 2026 | Nevada | Against Kalshi. Sports contracts treated as sports bets, not swaps. |
| 6th Circuit | September 25, 2026 | Ohio and Tennessee | Against Kalshi, on preliminary injunctions. |
| 4th Circuit | Argued May 7, 2026 | Maryland | No decision reported yet. |
| U.S. Supreme Court | Petition filed September 2, 2026 | New Jersey (No. 26-299) | Pending. Kalshi’s response deadline was moved to December 7. |
The CFTC has sided with Kalshi in some of this. The Block reported that the agency filed a brief backing Kalshi in the Ohio appeal, and CNBC reported that it has sued nine states over their efforts to regulate event contracts.
What has happened since the ruling
These updates come from news reports and a litigation tracker captured on November 7, 2026. Check the dockets for the latest.
- Rehearing request. Kalshi asked the full 6th Circuit to rehear the case. The tracker lists the filing as October 9, while another report says October 13. On October 28, the court told Ohio and Tennessee to respond by November 12. That is not a decision to grant rehearing, and full-court rehearings are rare.
- Supreme Court. New Jersey’s petition asks the justices to review the 3rd Circuit’s ruling. Reports say the NFL and a large group of state attorneys general backed it, and other companies have filed their own petitions.
- Missouri. On October 30, St. Louis Public Radio reported that Kalshi had sued Missouri in federal court after the attorney general issued a cease-and-desist order over sporting events. Kalshi says only the CFTC can oversee it, and that it differs from sportsbooks because it does not profit when customers lose. The attorney general’s office says a sports bet is sports betting wherever it is placed.
- Federal rulemaking. In June 2026, the CFTC proposed a framework for reviewing event contracts that involve activities such as gaming. A tracker also mentions a further CFTC rule in October, which we could not read.
If you are thinking about using one of these platforms
We cannot tell you whether a specific contract is legal where you live, because rules are shifting by state and by court. Here is how to protect yourself while it plays out.
- Confirm the legal age. A May 2026 trade-press report credited to NBC News said most states with regulated sportsbooks require bettors to be 21, while prediction-market sports contracts had been open to 18-year-olds. The NBA, PGA Tour and NCAA asked the CFTC to raise that to 21.
- Look up your state gaming regulator’s statement about the platform.
- Read the platform’s terms about where it is available, and expect them to change.
- Treat every contract as a wager that can lose everything you put in, and never use borrowed money.
- Set a limit before you start. If you want to win back a loss, close the app.
If gambling is getting out of hand, the National Problem Gambling Helpline is free, confidential and open 24/7 by call, text or chat. Call or text 1-800-MY-RESET, or call 1-800-522-4700. It is not an emergency line. In a crisis, call 911 or 988.
Frequently asked questions
Did the court say Kalshi is illegal in Ohio and Tennessee?
Not in so many words. It said Kalshi had not shown it can stop those states from applying their gambling laws, and it sent the Tennessee case back to the lower court. The underlying lawsuits continue.
What is a “swap,” and why does the label matter?
Under the Commodity Exchange Act, the CFTC has exclusive jurisdiction over swaps. Kalshi argues sports contracts are swaps, so only the federal agency can regulate them. The 6th Circuit read the definition narrowly and said Kalshi had not shown that.
Will the Supreme Court take the case?
Nobody knows yet. CNBC reported it is unclear whether the Court will act now or wait for more circuit rulings, though many expect the question to reach it eventually. The Court is not required to hear any pending petition.
Does this affect me if I live in another state?
Not automatically. Other courts have ruled differently, and states are acting on their own. Check your state’s gaming regulator rather than assuming.
Before you decide
Headlines make court news sound final. Before you treat a platform as “legal” or “banned,” check what your state regulator says, what the platform says about your state, and whether you meet the legal age. Skipping a contract entirely is a fine call too. The risk of losing money is the same no matter which label wins in court.
Sources
- Appeals court rules that states can regulate Kalshi’s sports prediction markets, dealing another legal blow to platforms – CNBC, September 25, 2026
- Kalshi loses appeal over Ohio and Tennessee sports betting laws, widening circuit split – The Block, September 26, 2026 (updated October 19, 2026)
- KalshiEX LLC v. SCHULER – Leagle (case caption, panel and dates for the 6th Circuit opinion of September 25, 2026; full text is behind a paywall)
- US court rules against Kalshi, says states can regulate prediction markets – Al Jazeera, September 25, 2026
- Kalshi Asks Full Sixth Circuit to Review Panel Decision Favoring Ohio and Tennessee Officials – DeFi Rate, October 14, 2026
- Prediction Market Lawsuit Tracker: Kalshi, Polymarket – DeFi Rate (captured November 7, 2026)
- Kalshi sues Missouri to prevent the state from regulating it | STLPR – St. Louis Public Radio, October 30, 2026
- CFTC Seeks Public Comment on Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Concerning Event Contracts Involving Enumerated Activities – U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission, June 10, 2026
- NBA, PGA and NCAA push for higher age minimum for sports prediction markets – CDC Gaming Reports, May 4, 2026 (credited to NBC News)
- About the National Problem Gambling Helpline™ – National Council on Problem Gambling – National Council on Problem Gambling
Last updated: November 2026. This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.















